The Pool Doctor's Exclusive
BUYER'S GUIDE
HOW TO BUY A POOL CLEANER
Choices, Choices, Choices
By last count there were over 150 automatic pool cleaners, a new assortment of
virtually identical garden hose cleaners and pool and spa wands. Add to
this the two or three central cleaning systems, plus of course the old, tried
and true, arduous traditional manual method. It's a daunting task.
We are the experts in the
industry having sold virtually every automatic cleaner there is, and researched,
tested and taken consumer and industry surveys of dealers and distributors.
Here's our recommendations:
1.) Decide What You Want To Remove From Your Pool.
Only our
Blue Line, the Aquabots (which
we do not recommend)
and our Battery-Powered
Pool Buster
Max CG Gold
and
EC Platinum and Silver inflatable pool cleaners can remove
microscopic debris.
Nothing else will work. Not Suction-Side (Kreepy
Kauleys, Baracuda, Haywards). No Pressure-Side
(Polaris, Letro and Hayward Viper and Phantoms).
Not Dolphins or TigerSharks. If you can live without
out cleaning fine sand, silt, algae,
disease-causing insect droppings, minutes stain-causing particles, then
consider something other than a robotic or
Pool Busters. With varying success, other cleaners may remove
larger debris, like stones, twigs, acorns
and leaves.
2.) Decide How Much
You Can Spend.
When
purchasing pool cleaners, not always, but most of the time you get what you pay
for. Our $749 Blue
Pearl is priced competitively with the
least expensive robotics,, despite being the # 2 rated pool cleaner in
the world. Pressure side cleaners require a
separate, energy-wasting booster pump, together with the
cleaner (Polaris, Hayward Viper, Letro) can
easily cost $500-$900, plus the cost of an electrician. But be
aware! Pressure-side cleaners are not
true vacuums. They
create a small amount of vacuum which will trap
larger debris as it passes by. On the low
end of the scale ($129-$450 are Suction-Side Cleaners like the
Kreepy Krauly, Baracuda and Hayward
Navigator. These no not vacuums either, but simply extended
vacuum heads.
Factor initial purchase price into your yearly operational costs.
Generally, the more expensive the
the cleaner, the more it does, and the less
your main filter and pump must do. Running a main filter
pump can cost up to 30 cents an hour just in
electricity. The more it works, the more debris it sucks in that
clogs the filter, and requires backwashing.
Backwashing wastes hundreds of gallons of water and the
chemicals in that water. The more you run your
main filter and pump, the more wear and tear on it, the
more wear and tear, the greater the chance for
breakdown and need for maintenance, and the shorter the
life of your entire system.
See our actual cost chart. Pressure and Suction side cleaners can cost you
over
$3.00 a day, just in electricity. 100 days later in the
first year you own your cleaner, and you've made up
the $300 difference in purchase price between the
inexpensive cleaner you purchased and a robotic, fully
independent cleaner.
3.) Do Your Homework.
Compare. Compare, Compare!
Pool Dealers
and Pool Service Companies very often have sell with a disturbing conflict of
interest.
Manufacturers like Polaris Pool Systems solicit
them all the time, and offer them sweetheart deals and even
vacations to Hawaii and other exotic vacations
based on a point system. They earn points by selling only
the manufacturer's products. We made a dramatic
change in our system by deciding not to sell the 150+
brands and models we did in the past, and
concentrate only on the very best pool cleaners in each
category. Use our charts!
|
Compare All
Types of Automatic Cleaners
Robotic v. Suction Side vs.
Pressure-Side)
|
Pool Buster vs. All Other Types
|
Robotic vs. Robotic
(Aquabot, Dolphin, TigerShark, etc.)
|
Pressure Side vs. Pressure Side
(Polaris, Letro, Hayward, etc.) |
Suction Side vs. Suction Side
(Kreepy,
Baracuda, Hayward)
|
Commercial vs. Commercial
(Aquamax, Dolphin, AquaVac.) |
10 Reasons NOT To Buy A Suction-Side Cleaner (Kreepy
Krauly, any Baracuda, any Hayward, any Sta-Rite, etc.)
All: 1.) Require installation; 2.) Or,
Require staying in the pool all the time; 3.) Are not really
vacuums, but extended vacuums heads (they do nothing independently); 4.) Cause
enormous wear and tear on your main filter and pump; 4.) Increase backwashing
needs;
5.) Reduce the suction power of your main filter and pump up to 50%; 6.) Result
in 2X
the amount of electricity being consumed; 7.) Have cumbersome, messy and ugly
hoses, which bake in the sun and rot in chlorine; 8) Require constant inspection
and
frequent maintenance; 9.) Do not remove fine debris, like algae and sand; 10.)
Are
all over the pool (random coverage of areas that are not even dirty) and do not
brush
(vibrating pads are not brushes; to brush, you need brushes!).
10 Reasons NOT To Buy A Pressure-Side Cleaner (Polaris,
Letro, Hayward Phantom or Viper, Baracuda Mars , etc.)
All: 1.) Require installation; 2.) Or,
Require staying in the pool all the time; 3.) Are not really
vacuums, but extended expensive versions of garden hose cleans, which have weak,
secondary vacuum-effect
for only the largest debris; 4.) Cause enormous wear and tear
on your main filter and pump (they do nothing independently); 5.) Increase
backwashing
needs; 6.) Reduce the suction power of your main filter and pump up to
50%; 6.) Result in
2-4Xs the amount of electricity being consumed; 7.) Have cumbersome, messy and
ugly
hoses, which bake in the sun and rot in chlorine; 8) Require constant inspection
and
frequent maintenance; 9.) Do not remove fine debris, like algae and sand; 10.)
Are
all over the pool (random coverage of areas that are not even dirty) and do not
brush
(vibrating pads are not brushes; to brush, you need brushes!).
AND
10 A.) Require
installation of energy-wasting (up to 40 amps per hour) booster pumps!
10 Reasons NOT To Buy An Aquabot:
All: 1.) Are either unproved new models, or
20-Year old technology; 2.) Clean in a slow,
ineffective, time wasting and maintenance-causing
Zig Zag cleaning pattern. 3.) Use
brittle, poor-climbing, immediately-deteriorating
old fashioned brushes; 4.) Generally
have a 1 year factory warranty (a sign of lack of confidence in their
durability); 5.) Wear
out far quicker than a Blue Diamond or Blue Pearl, requiring expensive repairs
or
replacement; 6.) Do not come with a convenient, practical caddy cart; 7.) Are
extremely
overpriced; 8.) Offer so many models, that the company does not concentrate it's
effort
building a few, well-tested models; 9.) Lack of one-the-spot, caring customer
service
as that
offered by Water Tech, manufacturer of the Blue Diamond and Blue Pearl;
10.) Do
not make periodic turns, required for full floor coverage.
)
10 Reasons NOT To Buy Dolphins
and
Tiger Sharks:
All: 1.) Are either unproved new models, or
30-Year old
technology; 2.) Clean in a very slow,
ineffective, time wasting and maintenance-
causing
Zig Zag cleaning pattern. 3.) Use
brittle, poor-climbing, immediately-deteriorating
old fashioned brushes; 4.)
Generally have a 1 year
factory warranty (a sign of lack of confidence in
their durability); 5.) Wear out far quicker than a
Blue Diamond or Blue Pearl, requiring expensive
repairs or replacement; 6.) Do not oil, hydro-
sealed in motor compartments, which are
necessary for lubrication, cool operation and
powerful suction; 7.) DO NOT FILTER ALGAE OR FINE SAND AND SILT' 8.) All parts
come from Israel, delaying repairs for weeks, if not months; 9.) Drive and
Pump Motor share a common motor case, requiring repair or replacement of both
motors whenever one is not working properly; 10.) Do not make periodic
turns, required for full floor coverage.