|
Side-By-Side
Comparison
of Major
Brand/Models
of Robotic
Cleaners
An
informed
buyer is our
best
customer.
Unlike most
other
e-merchants,
we are an
established
dealer,
with years
experience
in ool
research,
testing and
design. The
choice to
limit our
offerings in
robotic
cleaners to
the Blue
Diamond and
other Blue
Line
cleaners is
because we
only want to
sell the
best.
The
following
charts are
based on
information
published by
the
manufacturers,
occasionally
modified by
the vast
knowledge we
possess.
Numbers and
features
occasionally
change, and
even those
published by
the
manufacturer
are
sometimes
inconsistent*.
Therefore,
please use
this chart
and the
Buyer's
Guide on
each product
page as a
general
guideline to
assist in
your
ultimate
purchase.
Note 1: All
of these are
robotic
cleaners
with the
following
common
denominators,
with some
noted
exceptions:
Fully-independent,
Self-Contained
Filter, No
Installation,
Wall
Climbing,
Step-down
Transformers,
No Hoses, No
Booster
Pumps, No
Suction
Lines,
Reduced
Backwashing,
Eliminate
Manual
Brushing and
Vacuuming,
Minimum
Maintenance,
Great
Savings on
Electricity,
Chemicals
and
Water.
Note 2: No
cleaning
time are
given
because
shut-off
timers vary;
speed and
coverage
will provide
best
guideline.
Note: All
Cleaners
within a
single
column are
generally
private
labels or
duplication
under
different
names
manufactured
by the same
manufacturer
|
Brand/Model
|

Aquabot Mark
V/Classic
|

Aquabot Turbo/
Turbo G
|
|

AquaJet TigerShark
|

Dolphin Diagnostic
|

Blue Pearl
|

Blue Diamond
|

Aquabot
T-2
|
AquaJet
|
|
|
|
|
|

Aquabot
Pool Demon
|

Aquabot
Pool Demon
T
|
 |

TigerShark
Plus
|
|

Blue Diamond
RC
|

Aquabot T-4 |

Aquabot
Jet Demon AquaJet
Knock-Off
|
|

Aquabot
Storm
|

Aqua Tempo
|
|

TigerSharkQC
|

Dolphin Dynamic
|
|
Comments |
These are all
virtiually exact
copies of the
basic Aquabot
/Aquabot Mark
V
|
These are all
virtiually exact
copies of the
basic Aquabot
/Aquabot Mark
V |
These are all
virtiually exact
copies of the
basic Aquabot
Turbo Remote.
The Solo and
Speed Demon
differ as they
only have one
turning piston.
|
Aquavac
TigerSharks
are virtually
the same as
the Dolphins.
They differ
in that they
have a filter
cartridge, instead
of a bag, which
are expensive
to replace and
do not last
long.
|
Dolphins
are made in
Israel, and
employ single
motor boxes
for both moters,
meaning they
are expensive
to repair and
more subject
to breakdown.
|
This is
only marginally
shower version
of the Blue
Diamond, but
still faster
than any other
it's price class.
It is the
best bargain
among all 150+
automatic pool
cleaners
|
These are the
very best, most
functional pool
cleaners on
the market.
None are as
fast or durable.
All come
with a convenient
cart.
|
These
are cotninuing
to be experimented
with and modified.
The Power Wash
function is
insignificant
and subject
to breakdown.
|
Ineffictive
on viny pools.
Will not climb
and clean steps.
Mechanical with
no computer
guidance system.
|
|
Manufacturer
|
Aqua Products,
Inc.
|
Aqua Products,
Inc.
|
Aqua Products,
Inc. |
AquaVac
Systems
|
Maytronics,
Ltd.
|
WATER TECH,
LLC
|
WATER
TECH, LLC
|
Aqua Products,
Inc.
|
Aqua Products
for
AquaJet,
Inc.
Aqua Products,
Inc.
|
|
General
Description/
History
|
This is the
basic Aquabot
that is virtually
unchanged since
it was introduced
in 1982.
|
The most popular
of all Aqua
Products' cleaners.
This is a marginally
faster Aquabot,
relatively unchanged
for the last
ten years.
|
These employ
turning pistons
(except the
Plus model).
They tend to
stick and require
maintenance
and repair.
|
A literal clone
of the Dolphin,
virtually unchanged
for over five
years.
|
The granddaddy
of all wall-climbing
robotics.
Made in Israel.
Virtually unchanged
for thirty years.
|
The Baby
Blue Diamond
is a more affordable
version of the
World's Highest-Rated
and Most Acclaimed
Pool Cleaner.
|
The most technologically
advanced and
highest-quality
pool cleaner.
Tested extensively
in Europe, with
a track record
for longevity
and dependability
in the U.S.
for over five
years.
|
Only in its
second year,
still in it's
experimental
stage, it has
already been
changed for
2006.
|
A unique, so-called
"jet-powered"
cleaner, this
is basically
an idea that
never took hold
due to its inability
to scrub and
brush at all,
an inability
to climb as
well as the
other robotics.
Not recommended
in vinyl-lined
pools.
|
|
Guidance System
|
Computerized
Microprocessor
|
Computerized
Microprocessor
|
Computerized
Microprocessor
|
Computerized
Microprocessor
w/Memory Scanner
|
Computerized
Microprocessor
w/Memory Scanner
|
Computerized
Microprocessor.
|
Computerized
Microprocessor.
|
Computerized
Microprocessor
|
Mechanized
|
|
Cleaning Speed
/Coverage
Sq. Ft/Hr.
|
3500
|
6500
|
6500
|
2400
|
3000
|
5900
|
5900
|
7000
|
8600 (very
suspect)
|
|
Filter Power/
Gallons Per
Hour
|
4000
|
4200
|
4200
|
4500
|
4750
|
4015
|
4225
|
5000
|
5000 (very
suspect)
|
|
Note:
|
Ground
|
Speed and
|
Filtering
|
Power
|
Have
|
Never Been
|
Autenticated
|
By Any
|
Neutral
|
|
|
Testing
Lab
|
Neither
|
is an
|
Accurate
|
Measure
|
Of Actual
|
Cleaning
|
Time
|
|
|
Filter Porosity
|
2 Microns
|
2 Microns
|
2 Microns
|
5-20 Microns
|
2-30 Microns
|
2 Microns
|
2 Microns
|
2 Microns
|
2 Microns
|
|
Unit Weight
|
16.9 lbs.
|
18 lbs.
|
21 lbs
|
21 lbs (est.)
|
21 lbs
|
16 lbs.
|
16.5 lbs.
|
16.9 lbs.
|
11 lbs.
|
|
Cord Length
|
51'
|
60'/75'
on Turbo G
|
60'/75' on Turbo
Remote
|
55'/75'
Optional
|
60'
|
60'
|
60'
|
51'
|
40'
|
|
Distinguishing
Features
|
No shut-off
timer, allowing
separate purchase
of off and ON
timer.
|
Safety reset
switch. Enhanced
Climbing Tracks.
|
Wireless
2-Directional
Remote
(4-Directional
Remote on Plus)
|
Filter Cartridge
|
Cart Optional
|
Built-In
Safety Air Sensor,
and Obstacle
Sensor,
Super-Climbing
PVA Brushes
|
World-low 12
volt.
Twirling coverage
allowing 1 Hour
Cleaning.
Super-Hi-Tech
electronics.
Super-Climbing
PVA
Brushes. Free
cart.
|
No shut-off
timer, allowing
separate purchase
of off and ON
timer.
|
Powerwash Jets
in place of more
efficient brushes,
Jet-Powered
eliminating
replacement
drive belts,
tracks and motor.
Wpm't c;o,b
steps. No microprocessor,
but mechanical
directional
system.
|
|
Step Cleaning
Ability
|
Good
|
Very Good
|
Good
|
Good
|
Good
|
Excellent
|
Excellent
|
Good
|
None
|
|
Remote Control
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Available
on TigerShark
Plus.
|
Available
on Dolphin Dynamic.
|
No
|
Available
on Blue Diamond
Remote.
|
Available
on
T-4
|
No
|
|
Price Range
|
$700-$1000
|
$850-$1300
|
$1000-$1500
|
$700-$1000
|
$700-$1000
|
$1199
On Sale For
Only $749
|
$1300-$1500
|
$1400-$1700
|
$700-$900
|
The
following
are either
relatively
new/experimental
or obscure
models,
generally
available in
test
markets,
and
insignificant
enough to
not analyze
above.
|
|
|
Pentair Prowler 720
Not made
by Pentiare,
but in Israel--Similar
to Bravo
|
Pentair
Prowler 730-Remote
Not
made by Pentiare,
but in Israel--Similar
to Viva |
Aquabot Bravo and Viva
Very limited
distribution
-
|
Aquabot Ultrabot-Remote
Extremely
Expensive.
10-Year-Old
Design and
Technology
|
Zodiac (Baracuda) Indigo
Manufacturer
in France.
Very limited
distribution,
with no performance
statistics
published
(Perhaps they
have something
they do not
want consumers
to know)
|
See Our
Diversified Line-Up, A Pool Cleaner For Every Pool and Budget
|